CAPITAL NEWS ONLINE Vol. 24  No. 4  Mar. 20, 2009  Next Issue: Apr. 3, 2009
TOP STORY
capitalnews.ca
TOP STORY | NEWS | MULTIMEDIA | ARCHIVES ABOUT | HELP | ADVANCED SEARCH
PRINT: Space junk threatens Canadian satellitesSpace junk threatens Canadian satellites


OTTAWA  |  A massive cloud of space debris could damage or destroy two of Canada's most important observation satellites, says a Canadian space official.

The debris, caused by an earlier crash between two satellites, spans 1,500 kilometres in altitude, says Robert Saint-Jean, satellite manager at the Canadian Space Agency. The Canadian satellites, Radarsat-1 and Radarsat-2, pass through the orbit of the debris multiple times every day.

The orbit of the debris starts around 500 kilometres above the Earth's surface and stretches to approximately 2,000 kilometres in altitude.

Space junk explained

High-speed space garbage threatens Canadian national interests.
Requires FlashPlayer

"There is a very high risk for the two satellites,” says Saint-Jean.

The collision that caused the debris took place on Feb. 10 between the communications satellites Iridium 33 and Cosmos 255, owned by the United States and Russia, respectively.

It created more than 500 measurable chunks of debris, each bigger than a tennis ball, and millions of smaller pieces of junk, which can’t be tracked. The collision caused debris to fly into two intersecting orbits.

Debris in space travels at speeds of eight to nine kilometres per second; the average bullet travels at speeds of one kilometre per second.

Radarsat-1 and Radarsat-2 have a polar orbit, which means they circle the earth around the North Pole at 798 kilometres in altitude.

They make 14 rotations around the earth a day and collect data. This allows Canada to monitor ocean, land and ice development, which is used to manage resources and protect the environment.

The amount of energy contained in a single fleck of paint is enough to blast a hole through a windshield, says Ken Tapping, an astronomer with the Herztberg Institute of Astrophysics at Canada's National Research Council.

“Even very small things produce very large results,” he says.

This creates a problem because only items larger than 10 centimetres (about the size of a tennis ball) can be tracked. The millions of smaller pieces of debris are the biggest concern, says Tapping, because there is no way to tell if they're in a satellite’s path.

RADARSAT-1 floats high above Earth
Space debris could bring down two multi-million dollar Canadian satellites.

Should a part of either Radarsat satellite be damaged, Saint-Jean says repair would not be possible. If an intregal part were to break or be damged, the satellite would have to be replaced. The government has already invested almost a billion dollars in the Radarsat satellites.

You break it, you buy it   

Under international law the country that is liable for creating the debris must cover the cost of the damage the debris causes to other objects in space, says Ram Jakhu, an expert in space law at McGill University. But the country that owns the damaged satellite or shuttle must prove where the debris came from.

This is problematic because Canada relies on the U.S. to track the debris and to warn of impending collision, he says.

“There should be an international consortium of monitoring,” says Jakhu. “Information is power.”

Canada also relies on the U.S. for information on when and how to move the satellite to avoid debris, meaning it is at "the mercy of other states,” he says.

Stratcom, a branch of the U.S. Air Force, monitors space debris. In the event of collisions, it informs the North American Aerospace Defense Command (NORAD), which passes the information on to the Canadian Space Agency or MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd., the company that built and operates Radarsat-2.

Moving a satellite to avoid a collision is a very complicated process, says Saint-Jean.

“It’s not like in the movies,” he says. “You can’t just tell it to move a couple of feet to the right. That’s only in fiction. It takes a couple of days.

“Collisions are a matter of probabilities. It [the Feb. 10 collision] wasn’t even on their top 10 list.”

Space junk piling up

The collision did highlight the growing concern among the space community over space junk, says Tapping. In mid-March, two astronauts and a cosmonaut were evacuated from the International Space Station to an escape pod over fears of a collision with wayward debris.

The International Space Station as seen from space
Space junk almost forced astronauts to abandon the International Space Station in mid-March.

Humans have been polluting space since the USSR’s launch of Sputnik in 1957.

Shuttles and satellites that take off or are decommissioned leave debris, Tapping says.

There is also a risk from objects that collide or are purposefully destroyed, such as the Chinese satellite that was blown up this past January so China could test its anti-missile defence system. 

The collision of the two satellites in early February just emphasized the issue, says Tapping.

“We’ve been absolutely irresponsible about the way we’ve been using space,” says Tapping. “It’s not a matter of going at it with a catcher’s mitt or a big net. The best we can hope for is it [all the debris] will re-enter the atmosphere in the next 50 to 100 years.”

Related Links


Opens in a new windowCanadian Space Agency Satellites

Opens in a new windowNASA orbital debris program

Opens in a new windowSpace debris basics
Canadian satellite summary

Radarsat-1 and Radarsat-2 are Earth observation satellites built near Ottawa and owned by the Canadian company MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd.

The satellites use radar to bounce microwaves off of the Earth's surface, which are then turned into pictures.

Radarsat-1 was launched on Nov. 4, 1995 from an American air force base in California and Radarsat-2 was launched Dec. 14, 2007 from Baikonur Cosmodrome in Kazakhstan.

Whether it's day, night, cloudy, dusty, or snowy, the satellites can map the Antarctic, monitor oil spills and track ocean-going ships.

The cost of an image from Radarsat-1 ranges between $3,600 and $4,500 with additional costs involved in programming the satellite to take the pictures. Images from Radarsat-2 cost up to $5,400 per picture.

Souce: MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates, Canadian Space Agency.


The sky is falling

On average, one large piece of space debris falls back to Earth every day. Most of these objects break up and burn in the atmosphere, but some survive the fall and are found later.

Those that do survive usually fall in the ocean or in sparsely populated areas such as Siberia, the Australian outback or the Canadian tundra.

Intense gravitational forces (up to 10 times the force of gravity on Earth) break apart objects falling through the atmosphere. Most of the pieces then burn up in the atmosphere because of friction. Only materials with a very high melting point, like titanium, will reach the ground.

Only one person has ever been hit by re-entering debris, but was not injured because the piece was so light. A person has a one in a trillion chance of being hit by space debris. Comparatively, there is a one in 1.4 million chance of being hit by lightning.  

Source: NASA Orbital Debris Program Office, The Aerospace Corporation.


The laws of space

A 1972 treaty states countries that launch objects into space are responsible for the damage their debris causes to another country's property, including satellites.

The treaty, known as the Space Liability Convention, says the country that launches the object is responsible for any damage it causes, regardless of whether it was launching another country's satellite or rocket. Eighty-two countries, including Canada, have ratified the treaty.

One difficulty of the treaty is the country that suffered damage must prove which country is responsible. That can be difficult when the damage comes from an accident in space.

Though the treaty has never been used, Canada threatened to invoke it in 1978 after a nuclear-powered Soviet spy satellite named Cosmos 954 fell out of space and crashed in the Northwest Territories. It cost about $10 million to clean up the radioactive debris. The U.S.S.R. eventually paid Canada $3 million.

Source: McGill Institute of Air and Space Law, The Ottawa Citizen.


More Headlines
More resources needed for mentally ill offenders
Shaky economy rattles Canada's newest residents
To burn or not to burn: A smelly situation
Media Fund gets with the times
A huge welcome
Multimedia Feature
Surrounded by stress
Video Feature
Independent authors seek equality


Privacy Policy