| OTTAWA
| Feb.
9,
2007 — As
Canadians felt the sting of December's Christmas bills, NDP
MPs began receiving phone calls asking why some ATM service fees are
so high, says party finance critic Judy Wasylycia-Leis.
"People are being nickel-and-dimed to death by these ATM fees
and other fees and charges at a time when the banks have never been so
profitable," she said. While Canadians
must pay to withdraw their money, she says banks made $19 billion last
year. The party is drafting a private member's bill which will attempt
to amend Canada's Bank Act to ban automated
teller machine (ATM) fees.
 |
| Reporter Sara Parkes at her
local ATM. |
However, Melanie Minos, spokesperson for the Canadian Bankers Association
says the NDP are unfairly targeting banks when 69 per cent of ATMs are
privately-owned. She says such legislation is
also anti-customer, as it would lead to the customers paying more for
bank services to subsidize others' banking habits.
"It is not in the consumer's best interest to ban a fee that is
used to pay for the ABM network and it's one you can definitely avoid." She
says customers are told about network access fees before they proceed
with any transactions.
I decided to find out about my own ATM fees, and that’s
why I'm in this small office at my Scotiabank branch beside a row of
tellers.
The bank’s Mary Matheson analyzes my banking records. She tells
me with my Basic Banking chequing account, I can perform up to 50 monthly
transactions – provided I do them online or at a machine – for
about $7 a month. I often use point-of-purchase transactions – about
40 a month, but if I go over the limit, or go to a teller, I'm required
to pay 65 cents per transaction.
Taking account
"There are numerous types of accounts," Matheson says. "You
need to come in and make sure you have the right account for you."
Scotiabank's chequing accounts charge fees ranging from $3.95 to $11.95
a month. Some fees are completely waved when the account consistently
holds $2,000. If at any point the account dips below $2,000, the customer
must pay the regular monthly fee.
Matheson says another way to avoid additional fees is to use only your
bank’s ATMs.
"If you use Scotiabank machines, you don't have any additional
fees," says Matheson.
Banks charge $1.50 per ATM withdrawal using their services if you are
not a customer. Your own bank can also charge up to $1.90. Scotiabank
charges $1.50. Matheson says people can always transfer their accounts
to another bank, if they find they are frequently using that bank’s
ATMs. She also says to avoid private ATMs.
Avoiding private ATMs
"Those machines in Quickie stores that are not really bank machines,
they have charges that are even higher," she says. Private ATMs
often charge $2, even $3 per transaction, on top of the fees charged
by the customer's bank.
Wasylycia-Leis says Canadians often have no choice but to use privately-owned
ATMs, since there has been a trend across the country to close bank branches.
"They've pulled out of so many communities, shut branches down
completely and put in place either their own ATMs or let the private
ATMs come in. People have no choice."
 |
| Privately-owned ATMs can charge between $2 and
$3 per transaction. |
She said the NDP is encouraging banks to eliminate
fees while providing services in areas where private ATMs have taken
over. This way, there would be no need for privately-owned machines
which the federal government has no jurisdiction over, she says.
Back in the Scotiabank office, Matheson says I have a good bank account
for my lifestyle.
What did I discover? I have about 40 transactions
a month. I use other bank ATMs about once or twice and private ATMs barely
at all. My monthly bank fees are just over $7 and rarely above, due to
my infrequent use of competing ATMs.
So, yes, I am being forced to pay my bank to withdraw money from my
account, but with a low-fee account that suits me and a Scotiabank branch
located every few blocks in Ottawa, I have managed to avoid
being seriously gouged. Since I'm not prepared to close my account
and hold my money under a mattress, I suppose I will have to deal with
my fees.
|